Ethics Today Online
Published by the Ethics Resource Center
February 2007 Volume 5, Issue 3
** A Word from
the President: The Ethics Role of Human Resources
Although typically an ethics officer is
responsible for developing an organization's ethics policies, creating
communication related to the organization's code, planning ethics
training programs, and overseeing the ethics reporting function,
the most effective ethics officers know that it is also critical
to operate as part of a team that brings together many different
partners: finance, audit, operations, and especially human resources.
These individuals enlist the help of other critical groups throughout
their organizations, drawing on their knowledge and resources to
embed ethics throughout the organization's culture.
The human resources department is a particularly
important partner in efforts to promote ethical culture. As recruiters,
HR professionals determine who is invited to join the team. They
employ reward and punishment systems to reinforce what kind of behavior
is valued. They may use information gleaned from exit interviews
to support and improve the ethical environment. It is easy to see
that, apart from the ethics and compliance office, there is no other
department so critical to the development of an organization's ethical
culture as human resources.
In 2003, the Society for Human Resource
Management (SHRM) and Ethics Resource Center collaborated on a business
ethics survey of SHRM's membership. Of the HR professionals surveyed,
67% either agreed or strongly agreed that the human resources department
is a primary ethics resource for their organization. Similarly,
71% of those surveyed agreed or strongly agreed that HR professionals
are involved in formulating the ethics policy of their organization.
Recognizing the vital role that HR plays
in the development of ethical culture, the ERC Fellows focused their
January meeting on the ways in which HR professionals can work synergistically
with ethics and compliance officers to improve an organization's
ethical culture. I was pleased to share a podium with academic ERC
Fellow Linda Trevino, Professor of Organizational Behavior at Penn
State University, and ERC Board member Sue Meisinger, President
and CEO of the Society for Human Resource Management, who gave thoughtful
presentations full of research and experience on the role of HR
in organizational ethics. Find key highlights of their presentations
below.
During the ERC Fellows meeting, I was also
honored to present the 2006 Pace Award to an individual representing
another profession important to the ethical health of any organization
-- accounting. Charles Bowsher, former Comptroller General of the
United States and chairman of the Public Oversight Board, represents
all that is good about public service and graciously shared his
wisdom at a dinner in his honor.
As we move into the new year, ERC is busy
developing additional methods of disseminating information and research.
This month, ERC and Working Values, Ltd., will be sharing research
findings from the white paper announced in the last issue of Ethics
Today through a webinar entitled "Ethical Actions that Matter: Critical
Elements of an Ethical Culture." You will find more information
below about the February 27 seminar and how to register.
We are excited to share new developments
in the field and our research with you. We promise to keep you updated
with timely announcements of new research and programs that will
guide you in advancing high ethical standards and practices.
Patricia J. Harned, Ph.D
President, Ethics Resource Center
(Return to top of newsletter)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
** ERC Fellows
Discuss HR/Ethics and Compliance Office Relations
The ERC Fellows gathered in Potomac, MD,
January 17-19, to discuss HR/Ethics and Compliance Office Relations.
Presenters at the meeting included Pat Harned, ERC President; Linda
Trevino, Professor of Organizational Behavior at Penn State University;
and Sue Meisinger, President and CEO of the Society for Human Resource
Management (SHRM). In addition, Charles Ruthford, from The Boeing
Company; Dede O'Donnell, from SAIC; and Barbara Kuryk participated
on a panel that discussed the challenges and successes that the
HR and corporate ethics office might face when working together.
The Fellows heard updates from the five
active working groups, which cover:
- Measurement
- Incentives that Foster Ethical Conduct
- Defining the Role of the Chief Ethics
and Compliance Officer
- Risk Assessment
- Procedural Justice
The Fellows Program is made up of 76 members
overall from 41 member companies, including 61 corporate representatives,
9 academic invited fellows, 3 non-profit representatives, and 3
government liaisons.
Read more about the ERC Fellows Program
at:
http://www.ethics.org/fellows
(Return to top of newsletter)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
** The Key Role
of HR in Organizational Ethics
Linda K. Treviño is a Professor of Organizational
Behavior at the Pennsylvania State University is known primarily
for her unique focus on business ethics as a management issue. In
the area of business ethics, she has followed up her conceptual
work with empirical research that has contributed to knowledge regarding
the management of individual ethical conduct in organizations and
the management of organizational climate and culture to support
and encourage ethical behavior.
In a January 2007 presentation to the ERC
Fellows, she said that human resource professionals can and should
play a pivotal role in ethics management. Furthermore, research
suggests that successful ethics management depends more on employees'
fairness perceptions, ethical leadership at all levels, and the
alignment of multiple formal and informal cultural systems to support
ethical conduct than it does on formal ethics programs. To the extent
that HR systems invoke fairness evaluations, HR managers design
leadership training, and HR systems help to create and maintain
organizational culture, HR professionals must play a key role in
ethics management.
Read the synopsis of Linda Trevino's presentation
at:
Needs URL from LockMedia
(Return to top of newsletter)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
** HR's Role in
Creating an Ethical Culture, and How Ethics Officers Can Work With
HR
In a January 2007 presentation to the ERC
Fellows, SHRM President Sue Meisinger discussed several ways in
which HR can help build an ethical culture. These include:
- Building an infrastructure
- Staffing, including the selection of
leaders who will lead ethically.
- Orientation
- Training
- Employee relations
- Ensuring accountability through administration
of the performance management system
- Exit Interviews
(Return to top of newsletter)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
** Resources on
the Ethics Role of HR
On its website, SHRM offers a number of
documents that discuss the role of HR in cultivating an ethical
culture. These include:
The Ethics Squeeze
This articles sites real life examples of ethical dilemmas
reported by HR professionals and how they were resolved. An underlying
theme in these accounts is the presence of a management culture
that fosters ethical malfeasance or at least allows it to happen.
Often, HR is tasked with enforcing ethical and legal issues - and
that task sometimes ends in resignations.
Available to the public at:
http://www.shrm.org/hrmagazine/articles/0306/0306cover.asp
SHRM/ERC 2003 Business Ethics Survey
This survey explores ethical misconduct in today's workplace
from the perspective of HR professionals and considers the role
of HR professionals in developing ethics policies. Released April
2003.
Available for purchase at:
http://shrmstore.shrm.org/shrm/product.asp?dept%5Fid=19&pf%5Fid=62.17054
Experts: Ally HR with Ethics, Compliance Officers
An alliance between human resources and the ethics and compliance
officer requires that each department understand their own and the
other's roles and responsibilities. HR resources such as training,
offer letters and information obtained from exit interviews can
enhance substantially the creation and maintenance of an ethical
culture.
Available to SHRM members only at:
http://www.shrm.org/hrnews_published/archives/CMS_017150.asp
The Truth About Integrity Testing in Employment
In attempting to determine which employees will act with honesty
and integrity, many employers have used or considered using written
honesty or integrity tests. This article discusses why employers
use integrity and honesty tests, identifies different types of tests,
discusses their scientific validity of test, and points out possible
legal challenges. It also provides advice to employers contemplating
using such tests.
Available to SHRM members only at:
http://www.shrm.org/hrresources/lrpt_published/CMS_013085.asp#P-10_0
(Return to top of newsletter)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
** Fellows Present
2006 Pace Award to Charles A. Bowsher
In January, the ERC Fellows awarded the
2006 Pace Leadership in Ethics Award to Charles A. Bowsher, who
formerly served as comptroller general of the United States and
chairman of the Public Oversight Board (POB). In her nomination
of Mr. Bowsher, ERC Fellow Kathryn. Reimann, Citigroup Global Consumer
Group, said "Chuck has been an inspiration to many during his long
and diverse career of public service. . . He operates by a
set of unwavering principles and a strong commitment to those who
rely on him."
During a ceremony held at The Mansion at
Strathmore, ERC Chairman Stephen Potts spoke about the warmth and
humor of his long-time personal friend. Ms. Reimann recalled that
when he was a board member of American Express, Mr. Bowsher would
visit individual banks whenever he traveled to seek the opinion
of bank tellers and managers. She noted that these visits demonstrated
that the "top" was genuinely interested in how the company was run
and conveyed the importance of ethics to the everyday employee.
Mr. Bowsher recounted a similar story from
his early days on the board of Northrop Grumman when he visited
one of its ship-building docks and spent the day going through the
plant. While the employees found it remarkable that a board member
would spend an entire day with them, Mr. Bowsher thought his behavior
was simply good leadership.
Currently, Mr. Bowsher is an advisor to
the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), a public
member of the board of the National Association of Securities Dealers
(NASD), and serves on corporate, foundation and university boards.
He is also a recipient of distinguished public service awards from
the Department of the Navy and the Department of Defense.
Read the press release announcing his selection
at:
http://www.ethics.org/about-erc/press-releases.asp?aid=1041
(Return to top of newsletter)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Webinar: Ethical
Actions that Matter: Critical Elements of an Ethical Culture
A February 27, 2007, webinar will feature
ERC President Dr. Patricia Harned and ERC Research Analyst Laurie
Choi, and Working Values President David Gebler discussing how ethics
and compliance officers can make sure their programs and recommendations
have the greatest impact within their organizations.
The Ethics Resource Center's National Business
Ethics Survey (NBES®) is a key measurement of the impact
of culture on the effectiveness of ethics and compliance programs,
helping to guide business leaders in fostering ethical behavior.
Further ERC research commissioned by Working Values identified three
types of Ethics Related Actions that have a profound impact on outcomes
expected of an ethics program. Setting a good example, keeping promises
and commitments, and supporting others in adhering to ethics standards
can have a powerful influence on building an ethical culture.
This webinar will discuss the importance
of the ERC's research and how these results can be used to enhance
a company's ethics and compliance programs. The one-hour session
beginning at 2 PM EST is free but you must register in advance.
Get more information or register at:
https://www.gotomeeting.com/register/587216476
Download a copy of the white paper serving
as the background for this webinar at:
http://www.ethics.org/erc-publications/organizational-ethical-culture.asp
Working Values Ltd., a SmartPros company,
is a leading developer of integrated values-based corporate responsibility
and ethics awareness and compliance learning programs. Learn more
about Working Values at:
http://www.workingvalues.com
(Return to top of newsletter)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
** Compliance Week:
Personal Missteps Should Raise Eyebrows
[In August 2006, ERC President Patricia
Harned started contributing a monthly column on ethics to the well-known
national publication Compliance Week. This newsletter on corporate
governance, risk and compliance reaches over 40,000 financial and
legal executives at U.S. public companies electronically every Tuesday
morning and is published as a glossy print magazine on the first
day of the month. Compliance Week has granted permission for ERC
to reprint Dr. Harned's columns after they have appeared in both
the electronic and print versions. For more information about Compliance
Week or to subscribe, please visit http://www.complianceweek.com]
Many people firmly believe that what others
do in their private lives should not matter to the office, as long
as they are able to perform their jobs properly and safely. To a
large extent this is true. As the president of an organization myself,
I cannot (nor do I want to) tell my employees what they may or may
not do in their off-hours. That is, so long as they continue to
perform quality work, uphold our values statement, abide by our
employee manual and the law, and do not maliciously harm the organization.
Recently we've seen boards of directors
investigate and take action when chief executive officers engage
in behavior that generally is not associated their respective company's
moral standards. We've also read headlines of executive indiscretions
that likely forced board members to consider the best way to respond.
Time Warner's CFO Wayne Pace, Boeing's former CEO Harry Stonecifer,
and even the Department of Homeland Security's Deputy Press Secretary
Brian J. Doyle have faced difficult personal situations, which ended
up causing concern for their organizations. Sometimes it seems that
these leaders are forced out unfairly on the basis of rumor or gossip
or even "doing something everyone does." Is that right? At what
point do an executive's personal mistakes warrant board attention?
Read this column originally published in
the October 11, 2006, electronic edition of Compliance Week, at:
Needs URL from LockMedia
(Return to top of newsletter)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
** News, Publications
and Media Coverage
-- Martha Ries of Boeing Appointed
Chair Of Ethics Resource Center Fellows Program
January 16, 2007 -- M. Martha Ries, Vice
President - Ethics and Business Conduct at The Boeing Company, is
the new Chair of the Ethics Resource Center's Fellows Program.
ERC President Patricia Harned, Ph.D., announced the selection of
Ries by the Fellows' Advisory Panel.
"Martha Ries has outstanding credentials
in the development and implementation of corporate ethics principles
and practices," Harned said in announcing the appointment. "She
is committed, as are all of us at ERC, to building strong ethical
practices at all levels of our society. She will provide superb
leadership as the Fellows Program enters its second decade this
year."
Read this press release at:
http://www.ethics.org/about-erc/press-releases.asp?aid=1066
-- ERC Board Member Fred Fielding Returns as White House Counsel
January 18, 2007 -- President
Bush's appointment of Fred F. Fielding, Vice Chair of the ERC Board
of Directors, as his new White House counsel puts a strong advocate
for ethical principles in a critical Administration leadership post.
"We are delighted that Fred, an activist
on our board since 1993 and our Vice Chair since 2004, has been
selected for this key White House position," said ERC President
Patricia Harned, Ph.D. "He is well respected in Washington,
across party lines, for his devotion to the highest ethical principles
for our society."
Read this press release at:
http://www.ethics.org/about-erc/press-releases.asp?aid=1065
-- Ethics Resource Center Celebrates 85th Year Building Stronger
Ethical Foundation for Society
February 1, 2007 - Ethics Resource
Center - celebrating its 85th anniversary throughout 2007 - has
become the preeminent institution in the assessment of workplace
ethics environments and the promotion of a stronger ethical foundation
for society, in America and worldwide.
The oldest U.S. non-profit devoted to workplace
ethics, ERC and its predecessor institutions have since 1922 worked
to build a stronger society through evolving educational and research
initiatives. Today, ERC is active not only in traditional ethics
research but also as a strong voice in the public discussion of
what constitutes ethical behavior across the public and private
sectors.
"We are proud of our decades of service,
but longevity alone is not the true test of an organization," said
ERC President Patricia Harned in marking the 85th anniversary.
"Actual achievements - and how long they continue to affect society
- establish the institution's real value.
Read this press release at:
http://www.ethics.org/about-erc/press-releases.asp?aid=1075
(Return to top of newsletter)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
** Supporting Character
and Integrity
We extend our gratitude to everyone who
has contributed to the Ethics Resource Center this year. Without
your dedication and trust, many of the programs and projects highlighted
in this newsletter would not be possible.
The Ethics Resource Center achieves its
goals through its research, surveys and measurement tools, network
of international ethics centers and character education programs.
These programs can only continue through philanthropic support.
We invite you to join our loyal contributors in lending your support.
And now you can make a secure donation
online at:
https://www.ethics.org/store/donations.asp
The Ethics Resource Center (ERC) is a non-profit,
non-partisan educational organization exempt from taxation under
the Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. All gifts are
tax-deductible to the fullest extent of the law.
To find out more about how you can support
the ERC and its many programs, call 202-737-2258.
(Return to top of newsletter)
=======================================================
Please contact ethics@ethics.org
for information about reproducing any of the information contained
within this newsletter or on our web site.
Back issues of Ethics Today are available online at: http://www.ethics.org/erc-publications/ethics-today.asp
For questions about your subscription, please email ethicstodayonline@ethics.org
The Ethics Resource Center
1747 Pennsylvania Ave. NW
Suite 400
Washington, DC 20006
Telephone: 202-737-2258
http://www.ethics.org
Copyright © 2007 Ethics Resource Center. All rights reserved.